Wicksell

Taking Down a Take-Down: the James Montier edition

After eight drafts of your book, an unsettling dread creeps up on you. Certain parts that once seemed genius now strike you as half-baked. Your writing is meandering and unstructured. You can spot the places where you resisted the urge to think deeply. You shove in quotes and calls to authority more than you should, all the while laughing obnoxiously at seasoned “experts”— never, ever forget the ironic quotation marks.

Why? Because, well, it feels pretty good to be a gangster.

James Montier, in his latest white paper, tries very hard to be a gangster. But he fails – miserably. I know because I’ve been there. In fact, I often go there. Even so, I know a huckster when I see one. And in his “exposé” on the “myth” of the natural rate, James Montier is nothing more than a charlatan.

Advertisements